Natural Gas Prices Should Double

Posted in The Petroleum Truth Report on April 7, 2016

Natural gas prices should double over the next year.

Over-supply plus a warm 2015-2016 winter have resulted in low gas prices. That is about to change because supply is decreasing (Figure 1).

Supply Balance_STEO_JAN 2016 Natural Gas 24 Jan 2016

Figure 1. EIA U.S. natural gas supply balance and forecast. Production, consumption and supply balance values are 12-month moving averages. Source: EIA and Labyrinth Consulting Services, Inc.

Total supply–dry gas production plus net imports–has been declining since October 2015* because gas production is flat, imports are decreasing and exports are increasing. Shale gas production has stopped growing and conventional gas has been declining for the past 15 years. As a result, the supply surplus that has existed since December 2014 is disappearing and will move into deficit by November 2016 according to data in the EIA March STEO (Short Term Energy Outlook) .

During the last supply deficit from December 2012 to November 2014, Henry Hub spot prices averaged $4.05 per mmBtu. Prices averaged $1.99 per mmBtu in the first quarter of 2016 so it is reasonable that prices may double during the next period of deficit.

EIA forecasts that gas prices will increase to $3.31 by the end of 2017 but that is overly conservative because it assumes an immediate and improbable return to production growth once the supply deficit and higher prices are established (Figure 1).

Production companies are in financial distress and are unlikely to return to gas drilling at the $2.75 price that EIA forecasts for November 2016. The oil-field service industry is in disarray and is probably unable to reassemble drilling and fracking crews and equipment in less than 6 to 12 months after demand resumes.

There are currently on 92 rigs drilling for gas. That is 150 rigs less than the previous record-low set in 1992 (Figure 2). Production cannot be maintained at this level despite unrealistic faith in drilling efficiency and spare capacity from uncompleted wells.

Gas Directed Rig Count

Figure 2. U.S. gas-directed rig count, 1987-2016. Source: Baker Hughes and Labyrinth Consulting Services, Inc.

A Tale of Two Price Cycles  

Storage and production patterns for 2015 – 2016 appear quite similar to patterns observed in 2011 – 2012. Both periods are characterized by exceptionally high storage and comparative inventory levels, and record-low spot gas prices.

The storage and comparative inventory surplus of October 2011 – March 2012 disappeared as gas supply fell in response to low prices (Figure 3). By April 2013, gas prices were near $4.20 because the surplus had become a deficit. A cold winter sent prices above $6.00 in February 2014.

A similar pattern may be occurring in 2016.

The monthly average Henry Hub price for gas in March 2016 was $1.71 per mmBtu. That is the lowest CPI-adjusted monthly price (February 2016 dollars) in 40 years (Figure 3 shows 1999-present).  The previous record low price was $2.01 in April 2012. The 2012 low coincided with a comparative inventory peak followed by an inventory deficit and gas prices that exceeded $4.00 by December 2013. The current 2016 price low must be near the latest comparative inventory peak.

CPI-HH & CI 1999-2016

Figure 3. U.S. natural gas storage and CPI-adjusted Henry Hub spot price in February 2016 dollars per mmBtu. Source: EIA, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and Labyrinth Consulting Services, Inc.

Comparative inventory is a measure of gas storage volume compared to a moving average of inventory values for the same time period over the 5 previous years. Comparative inventory (CI) provides an excellent negative correlation with natural gas spot prices.

Absolute storage levels were nearly the same for the last week of March 2016 (2,468 Bcf) and the last week of March 2012 (2,472 Bcf), and 2016 appears to be trending lower relative to 2012 (Figure 4).

Comparison of Gas Storage Levels 2012-2016 HH-CI-FUTURES 19 MARCH 2016

Figure 4. Comparison of U.S. natural gas storage levels, 2012-2016. Source EIA and Labyrinth Consulting Services, Inc.

Gas production was flat from February 2012 through December 2013 in response to the price collapse that culminated in April 2012 (Figure 5). The price minimum coincided with a supply surplus maximum that disappeared and became a supply deficit by February 2013.

Chart_PROD-SUP BAL-HH 2008-16

Figure 5. Dry gas production, Henry Hub prices and total supply surplus or deficit. Supply surplus and deficit values represent 12-month moving averages as in Figure 1. Source: EIA and Labyrinth Consulting Services, Inc.

Gas production has been flat since September 2015 (Figure 5).  Total dry gas production in March 2016 was 0.7 bcfd less than in September 2015 and the latest EIA data indicates that production for April is 1.2% (-0.83 bcfd) less than a year ago. EIA’s supply forecast (Figure 1) suggests that the present surplus will become a deficit later in 2016.

Why Natural Gas Prices Will Double

I used the EIA March 2016 STEO inventory forecast to calculate comparative inventory for the rest of 2016 and 2017.  This data indicates a fall in comparative inventory beginning in April or May 2016 (Figure 6).

EIA & Berman Gas CI and Price Forecast

Figure 6. U.S. natural gas comparative inventory, Henry Hub price and forecast. Source: EIA and Labyrinth Consulting Services, Inc.

That should result in a return to higher gas prices. The price estimate based on comparative inventory (shown in red) is more bullish than EIA’s price forecast (shown in orange) but both indicate a substantial percentage increase in prices.

EIA forecasts $3.10 gas prices in January and February 2017, and $3.31 in December 2017. My forecast based on comparative inventories is about 15% higher overall than EIA’s but peak prices are 20-30% higher.  It calls for winter prices in the $4-range for 2016 and 2017.

Putting Prices In Perspective

A doubling of gas prices to $4.00 per mmBtu may seem overly optimistic based on current price levels that have averaged about $2.00 since the beginning of 2016. Yet average prices since 1976 are $4.61 in 2016 dollars and the modal value for that period is $3.50 (Figure 7).

CPI WTI & HH 22 March 2016

Figure 7. CPI-adjusted Henry Hub price and forecast (February 2016 dollars per mmBtu. Source: EIA, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and Labyrinth Consulting Services, Inc.

Moreover, the average price since January 2009 is $3.80 (2016 dollars) and the long-term trend-line is above $5.00 per mmBtu. All the data presented in this analysis suggests that present prices represent the low point in a price cycle similar to 2012-2014 in which $2 gas was the low point in an overall cycle whose average price was $3.65. That price is consistent with average prices since 2009 and the long-term modal price. The average of 2012-2014 peak prices (November 2013-December 2014 period negative comparative inventory–Figure 6) was $4.34 per mmBtu.

My forecast for gas prices to average $3.65 in 2017 (Figure 6) is quite conservative. It is based on the dubious EIA assumption that producers will quickly respond to a an increase in gas prices to about $2.35 per mmBtu (their forecast price) and that production will increase strongly throughout the rest of 2016 and 2017.

That is what happened in early 2014 (Figure 5) but then, gas prices were more than $6 and external capital was readily available before the oil-price collapse that began later that year. Although capital is still available, companies are more likely use it to pay down debt than to resume drilling especially for gas at least for the rest of 2016 and possibly longer.

The days of pure gas players are pretty much over and liquids are a more attractive drilling target at any price than natural gas. Having said that, the best operators (Cabot, EQT and Chesapeake) in the Marcellus Shale play need $3.50 to $4.00 gas prices to break even and most need $4.25 to $5.50. In the Utica and Woodford plays, most operators need at least $5.00 to $6.00 prices to break even.

February gas production has declined 0.7 bcfd from its peak in September 2015. EIA’s production forecast calls for a 1 bcfd increase by December 2016 and an almost 3 bcfd increase by December 2017. It is difficult to imagine that either price forecast shown in Figure 6 would result in the drilling resurgence necessary to realize those higher rates.

That is why it is probably conservative to suggest that gas prices will double in the next year or so.

10 comments on this entry

  1. “EIA forecasts $3.20 gas prices in January and February 2016, and $3.41 in December 2017. My forecast based on comparative inventories is about 15% higher overall than EIA’s but peak prices are 20-30% higher. It calls for winter prices in the $4-range for 2016 and 2017.”

    Art – Shouldn’t the above be gas prices of $3.20 in January and February 2017 (not 2016). Regards, and thank for your article on US natural gas looking forward.

  2. Daniel,

    Thanks for noticing those errors.

    I have corrected the text as follows:

    “EIA forecasts $3.10 gas prices in January and February 2017, and $3.31 in December 2017. My forecast based on comparative inventories is about 15% higher overall than EIA’s but peak prices are 20-30% higher. It calls for winter prices in the $4-range for 2016 and 2017.”

    The latest April EIA STEO data shows an upward revision in Henry Hub price forecasts to $3.20 by January-February 2017 and $3.42 by December 2017.

    All the best,


  3. What do you think of S-2012 ( Senate Bill ) which supports additional exportation of US LNG. Are the law makers out of touch with the natural gas reserves we have or do not have. After reading the Senate Bill, the law makers seem to be convinced that the US has all the natural gas we need and that exporting our US LNG is a great idea.

    What’s your opinion on this line of thinking regarding an over abundance of US natural gas? I’ve read your articles which question the amount of natural gas reserves we have in the US based on data, not just hype or hope of over estimated gas reserves. Regards.

  4. Daniel,

    The mainstream view is that the United States has infinite cheap natural gas reserves. I recently saw a report that claims that there are 500 years of supply remaining in the Marcellus Shale. The natural gas industry has done a masterful job of convincing policy makers that the U.S. is going to change the geopolitical balance of the world because it is the king of gas. Never mind that we are a distant 5th largest reserve holder in the world.

    Beyond the recent post on natural gas, I show in a previous post that our exports will accelerate our future supply deficit.

    I worked with Ron Weyden the previous chair of the Senate Committee on Natural Resources but he proved to be more interested in his own career path that carrying the message of natural gas export as lunacy.

    All the best,


  5. Art,

    Mercy, 500 years supply just in the Marcellus! And I thought the 200 year supply that was hyped up by the media was high. Thanks for your reply, and your 2 articles with figures which are pretty straight forward regarding US natural gas reserves. Regards.

  6. HI art, you think AECO price could go up due to your estimation about US supply deficit by nov 2016?

  7. […] in 2017. Latest data from EIA corroborate the impending late 2016 supply deficit that I wrote about last month (Figure […]

  8. […] in 2017. Latest data from EIA corroborate the impending late 2016 supply deficit that I wrote about last month (Figure […]

  9. Hi Art-
    Would it be possible to update your thoughts on NG prices/supply demand at some point.
    thank you and looking forward to listening to the macro voices podcast.

  10. updated email